Skip to content

Workforce

Author: Laura Francis

Posted on September 29, 2002June 29, 2023

Rude HR Pros Give the Whole Field a Bad Image

Your attitude is going to get you in troublesomeday.


    That was my mother’s favorite line when I was growing up, and more oftenthan not, my attitude got me in trouble right then and there. But hey, I was 12,and going through those fascinating hormonal changes that all adolescents havethe pleasure of experiencing. I like to think that I have grown out of theantagonistic, eye-rolling phase of juveniles and matured into a responsibleadult who respects and appreciates others. This doesn’t seem to be so unusualan ambition. So why is it that I often feel like the only one in the worldattempting to accomplish this?

   Acts of rude behavior and lack of common courtesy seem to increase everyyear. From people who refuse to use turn signals when they are driving to peoplewho play their car stereos extremely loud (thanks, but I listen to my ownmusic), and from people who don’t hold the door for others who are walkingright behind them to people who walk in front of others without saying “excuseme,” I feel bombarded with rude behavior wherever I go. The cashiers at thelocal grocery store are rude; the people in my office building are rude; thecustomer-service agents at my health-insurance company are rude.


   I’ve even experienced rude behavior and lack of manners from people in HR.


   When I was looking for a job two years ago, I sent out about 50 résumés tolocal and national employers. I received a total of four acknowledgments that myrésumé had been received. Four out of 50 is a pretty poor percentage ofresponses. I wasn’t expecting that they would all send back handwrittenletters that gushed over my qualifications and begged me to come work for them,but a form letter or even one of those prepaid postcards with the standard spielacknowledging the fact that I had sent my résumé would have been nice.


   I was taught to send thank-you notes and personal letters to people as a wayto acknowledge a gift or kind thought, and every career coach out there willtell you to send a handwritten thank-you note after an interview. Why does itseem that this courtesy cannot be reciprocated by HR? Is it too much to ask thatthey acknowledge my résumé and desire for employment with a prewrittenpostcard? As it was, I didn’t even get that 46 out of 50 times.


   When I called employers to follow up, the people I spoke to often sounded putout that their busy day had been interrupted by my call (I will not mention thattaking my phone call was part of their job) and shocked that I had the audacityto contact them when they had clearly not cared enough to contact me. These verypeople who are a first contact for many potential employees, and who many wouldthink should act with at least a bit of professionalism, were in fact the veryembodiment of rudeness. I realize that not all HR professionals act this way,but those who do give the rest a bad name.


   What is going on? Whatever happened to common courtesy? Whatever happened toemployees (especially those in customer-service positions) treating customers asif they matter? Whatever happened to people caring about one another? Thesequestions haunt me every time I witness rude behavior. Unfortunately, this trendcontinues to grow, and I am beginning to see it in younger people every day.


   I cannot count the number of times I’ve heard a teenager say “whatever”in response to a request (as in, “Molly, can you vacuum the living room today?”“Whatever.”). What can be done to address this problem? Is this just atraining issue for HR professionals to handle once these rude people become rudeemployees? Is it an educational-system issue? Is it a parental issue? Is it aHollywood celebrity-syndrome issue? (Imagine pop princess Britney Spearsflipping off photographers in Mexico.)


   In my opinion, it must be a community issue. We all have to care that thisrude and obnoxious behavior is occurring, and then make a commitment to changeit. Without widespread concern and acknowledgment that this kind of behavior isunacceptable, I foresee no end to rampant rudeness.


   I may not have wanted to admit it when I was 12, but I think my mom wasright. It is all about attitude. A kind and courteous attitude can do wondersfor you and those around you; a bad one can have just as pervasive an impact,although with completely different results.


Workforce Online, October 2002 — Register Now!

Posted on April 20, 2001July 10, 2018

Sports and Salaries Lets Get Real

With the dawning of spring comes many things — daylight savings time; rain,flowers and birdsong; uncontrollable sneezing; and the rebirth of the nation’spastime. However, along with baseball come baseball players and theirpocketbooks.


    The overblown salaries of baseball players today should cause us to pause andask questions. Why, in an age when hardworking individuals are struggling tomake ends meet, are there grown men playing a game that pays them millions ofdollars? Why do we stand by and let it happen? Why do we feed this nationaladdiction of sports heroism? Why am I the only one who cares?


    Does it concern anyone else that America is now laying off thousands ofworkers at the same time that Alex Rodriguez begins the baseball season with acontract that will pay him $252 million over 10 years? Shouldn’t we all beconcerned? When it comes down to it, we’re really all to blame for thisout-of-whack financial sense. Yep, I said we.


    Any one of us who patron baseball games, buy team merchandise, and pay theridiculous $4 for a hotdog at the stadium are fostering the unnatural and highlycontagious disease of overblown salaryitis. While it pains me to admit it, I tooam guilty of the offense. There’s something about the peanut dust clinging to myhands and the way spending $7 on a beer can make the most basic of domesticstaste like the purest of brews. Once per season I have to make my way to theballpark to breathe in the dust from the infield.


    Can I justify my actions? No. Every year the urge to see the boys of summerplay some long ball overwhelms me and I give in. Yet, the more I think about it,the more irrational and ridiculous my actions seem. And the same could be saidfor all of us who patron baseball games and feed into the mindset that it’s okayand normal to pay people millions of dollars to play a game.


    Can you picture yourself justifying to your CEO how you offered a potentialemployee $252 million for an average of four hours of work a day for fivemonths? No? Me neither. No one in his right mind in the HR world would ever dosomething as crazy as that.


    Or would they?


    Look at all those crazy dot-com companies who offer newemployees gamerooms, swimming pools at work, and brand new sports cars. The companies had themoney to spend (obviously), but should they have done so?


    Companies, like professional sports, flex their monetary muscles by spendingexorbitant amounts on new recruits, believing this was the only way to wooprospective employees away from competitors. Also, they believe it is the onlyway to keep current employees away other companies. Are we surprised to see thebusiness practices of professional sports bleeding over into the corporateworld? We shouldn’t be.


    Which leads me to the $252 million question: Why do we accept and even expectthe huge salaries paid to professional athletes?


    Maybe we shouldn’t. Instead of letting the sports world lead our nation’seconomic mindset, we should create a new trend and let the business realminfluence the way people think of money and salaries. And when I say businessrealm, I don’t mean those dot-coms that flooded society with over-compensatedemployees. I mean the real business world, the one most of us work in.


    So here’s my idea. Instead of paying players great sums of money for littlework, professional sports should take a page out of the HR manual at anybusiness — a lot of work for little money. That’s the way the world really works.


    We’d like to pretend we work for companies that would pay us handsomely andallow us to take every Monday and Friday off, but this isn’t a movie. It’s life.I’m sorry to have to be the one who breaks the news to you, but those types ofjobs don’t exist.


    The majority of people know (that is to say we working stiffs out there) thatit’s damn tough work to hold down a 9 to 5 job. We have to show up for work dayafter day, week after week and two weeks’ vacation, which half the time we feeltoo guilty or are too busy to use. Yet, we still patron functions that pay theiremployees millions of dollars, rubbing in our faces that we will never make asmuch for doing so little as those professional athletes.


    So while the boys of summer go out there and play a game, I, on behalf of allthe other poor working schleps out there, feel justified in my tirade thatplayers are overpaid and under worked. Workers of the world, unite! Professionalathletes of the world, get real jobs.


 

Webinars

 

White Papers

 

 
  • Topics

    • Benefits
    • Compensation
    • HR Administration
    • Legal
    • Recruitment
    • Staffing Management
    • Training
    • Technology
    • Workplace Culture
  • Resources

    • Subscribe
    • Current Issue
    • Email Sign Up
    • Contribute
    • Research
    • Awards
    • White Papers
  • Events

    • Upcoming Events
    • Webinars
    • Spotlight Webinars
    • Speakers Bureau
    • Custom Events
  • Follow Us

    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • RSS
  • Advertise

    • Editorial Calendar
    • Media Kit
    • Contact a Strategy Consultant
    • Vendor Directory
  • About Us

    • Our Company
    • Our Team
    • Press
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms Of Use
Proudly powered by WordPress